How BAD Ideas Can Turn Into GREAT Tracks

You’re onto a good idea in the studio. 

Maybe you spent a few hours producing up this little hook, chord sequence or groove. The next morning you enthusiastically fire up the computer, listen back, and…


…let’s be kind and describe it as “incredibly underwhelming”. 

Looks like you just had a visit from the Mediocre Fairies. 

Those little guys have paid me a visit more times than I care to admit.

But most bad ideas are only a couple of chess moves away from becoming very usable ideas.

Perhaps a little change to the instrumentation, switching out a chord or two, a little production magic, or even a bold tempo change can launch an idea in a new, workable direction. Suddenly you’re in flow and it all feels gloriously downhill. 


Miss, miss, strike: Charlie Puth


Charlie Puth produced a top 10 hit entirely from a home studio set up probably not too dissimilar to yours.

However, this track, “Attention”, took some pretty major wrong turns before it became one of the songs of 2018.

The upbeat Pop track’s first incarnation was what Puth describes as “a sad, depressing Piano ballad”Persevering to a more upbeat version, his subsequent pizzicato strings hook idea sounded “…really stupid. It sounds like a Disney movie.” 

Cue more persevering, this time by layering Guitar samples. And now finally, there’s traction.

You can see Charlie himself walk us through this process, along with a whole load of other neat production touches he uses, in the video below.


Persevere Via Bold Changes


So whether you’re writing Pop tracks or Soundtracks, I’d strongly suggest persevering with those tracks that don’t seem to work as is. If things aren’t working, don’t be afraid of making sweeping, bold changes.

Alternatively, if things aren’t heading in a direction suitable for the project you’re working on and time is at a premium, create a “Ideas In Progress” file for those DAW sessions and come back to them later.

I imagine Charlie is quite happy he didn’t give up on that depressing Piano ballad.



  1. Avatar
    1. Michael Kruk Post
      Michael Kruk

      Thanks Laurel! Glad you enjoyed it!

  2. Avatar
    Dan Weber

    I have tracks like that in my “Mediocre Fairy” Library, haha. Glad to see a hit Songwriter goes through the same things I do. Thanks, Michael !

    1. Michael Kruk Post
      Michael Kruk

      I think that the mediocre fairy unfortunately visits us all from time to time!! 🙂

  3. Avatar
    1. Michael Kruk Post
      Michael Kruk

      Thanks Ron, glad you enjoyed it!

  4. Avatar
    Michael Cirasuolo

    Really great to see the process happening right before you, and knowing that your not
    doing much different than Charlie production wise. Which means with a couple of the
    right inspirations you could finish that #1 hit you had sitting idle for years!
    Thanks again Michael as always much appreciated

    1. Michael Kruk Post
      Michael Kruk

      Agreed Michael – I wish more successful artists would post about their create dead ends – it’s actually quite encouraging!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *